Conflict in the world of WordPress: The other side of the coin

Article image Conflict in the world of WordPress: The other side of the coin
Article image Conflict in the world of WordPress: The other side of the coin
Publication date:22.10.2025
Blog category: Web Technology News

Attorneys for Matt Mullenweg and Automattic filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit against WP Engine, providing a different perspective on the reasons for this conflict. According to them, it is not Mullenweg and Automattic that are at fault, but WP Engine, which requires the defendant to provide resources and support for free and limits Mullenweg's ability to express its opinions about WP Engine's practices.

“But the success and viability of WordPress depends on a supportive and symbiotic relationship with those in the WordPress community.”

🚀 After defining what the community is, how it was founded, and the role that Mullenweg and Automattic play as very supportive of the community, they describe WP Engine as a company that gets huge benefits from volunteer work and donated time without giving enough back to the community. This is the part that Mullenweg and Automattic believe WP Engine left out of their complaint, that Mullenweg was expressing his opinion that WP Engine should be more supportive of the community, and that Mullenweg was responding to the threat posed by the plaintiff's conduct.

  • 📌 The key idea is that the WordPress community, as an open project, depends on a "symbiotic" relationship between community members, including web hosts like WP Engine.
Q: What is the conflict between WP Engine and Mullenweg? A: WP Engine is suing Mullenweg and Automattic for damages. However, Mullenweg claims that WP Engine is actually using WordPress resources without properly compensating the community. Q: What is WordPress? A: WordPress is an open content management system used by millions of sites around the world. Q: What is Automattic? A: Automattic is a company that develops several popular products, including WordPress.com, WooCommerce, Jetpack and others.
🧩 Bottom line: From Mullenweg and Automattic's point of view, WP Engine uses WordPress resources and makes big profits from volunteer work without giving enough back to the community. They believe that WP Engine should provide more support to the community and agree to license terms with Automattic.
🧠 Own thoughts: This conflict reminds us of the importance of mutual support in the open source community. If a company benefits from using open source, it should find ways to give back to the community it benefits from. This could include contributing to code, sponsoring events, or even just publicly acknowledging the role of open source in your success.